Bite into wine & cheese: a grate combination
This issue was published on April 5, 2023.
Happy Wine Wednesday!
We’re here to level up your wine game and celebrate the women who work in wine, all while having a grape time.
Today, we’re biting into the history and science behind wine and cheese pairings, then talking to multi-hyphenate sommelier Stacey Gibson about everything from wine and food pairings to balancing parenthood and owning a business.
So pour yourself a glass and let’s get our wine nerd on!
Wine & Cheese
Salt, Fat, Acid, Tannins
Today, we’re going to talk about the deliciousness that is wine and cheese so you can impress guests at your next dinner party!
First off, let’s look at their origins. Historians have found records dating back hundreds of years that show a correlation between the geographical origins of wines and cheeses. For example, the Italian Asiago cheese is often paired with a Chianti or Brunello – both wines from a similar region. “What grows together goes together,” and in this case, they’ve been growing together for centuries. Pairing wine and cheeses this way is a great place to start!
For example, you can pair a tangy French goat cheese from the Loire Valley with a Sancerre or Pouilly-Fumé (both sauvignon blancs from the same region), or pair the Spanish sheep’s milk cheese Manchego with a bold Monastrell from Southern Spain (you may know Monastrell by it’s French name, Mourvédre, where it’s the “M” in a Rhône/GSM blend).
Another saying you may have heard is that opposites attract: Foods that are opposites of each other on the taste spectrum often create great pairings. In this case, the astringency of the wine (that might make your mouth feel dry or cause you to pucker) beautifully balances the fatty, oily mouthfeel of cheese. It’s similar to how you add acid when you’re cooking to cut through the fat!
Tea and coffee, also astringent and with tannins, are another great example. One of the most common things to put in tea and coffee? Milk! It’s the same concept. Does this mean you can pair your morning caffeine with cheese? Yes, like a bagel with cream cheese or a breakfast sandwich with cheddar! Also, there’s an espresso martini with parmesan cheese (!!!) that went viral recently that I haven’t tried yet but I’ve heard is delicious. If you’ve made it, please report back. I need to know: Can it really be that good?!
Anyway –Back to wine and cheese.
The other thing to remember is that both are agricultural products that can be enjoyed young or after some aging. Younger cheeses tend to be lighter and more delicate, similar to how younger wines can be more fresh and bright. Older cheeses, which lose water-content over time, become richer in flavor and have increased fat content. In the same way, older wines may be more complex with notes like toast from the barrels they were aged in.
Ideally, your wine and cheese have a similar body and intensity so that one doesn’t overpower the other. This means that a lighter, fresh wine will pair better with a younger cheese, while a wine with more intensity will be better suited to handle an older cheese. For example, you might want to eat aged cheeses like Gouda, Parmesan, or Manchego with a bolder red wine so that the higher fat content can cut through the higher tannins in the red wine. On the other hand, a younger, bright white wine could get overpowered by these cheeses.
Speaking of intensity…Who loves funky cheese? (Me!)
Time to cut that funk with some sugar! The sweetness in your Moscato, Gewürztraminer, dessert wines, and Port will help balance out the wonderful stink of washed-rind and blue cheeses. Two classic pairings for the blue cheese lovers out there are Port with Stilton and Sauternes with Roquefort. Perhaps this is the opportunity to persuade your blue-cheese-reluctant friend to finally give it a try..?
I know, I know. You’re like, “I have a bottle of X and I just need to know what to pick up at Trader Joe’s!” Don’t worry, I got you.
Here is an incomplete but good rule of thumb guide:
Sparkling: One of the most versatile of the bunch! Just skip the stinky blue cheese or ones with some extra umami like cheddar, gouda, and muenster. Otherwise, you’re good to go with anything from gruyere, queso fresco, cream cheese (hello, breakfast bagel), to parmesan, gruyere, brie…you get the picture.
White wines: You can’t go wrong with a creamy, buttery cheese like brie, burrata, a nutty, hard cheese like gruyere, provolone, or even a stinkier wash-rind cheese like Époisses. Your wine will probably get overpowered by a blue cheese, so unless you have an aromatic white wine (like a Riesling) that can stand up to the cheese, you might want to leave that in the fridge for another time.
Rosé: I have bad news. It’s not looking great for a cheese pairing here… If you must, go with something more salty and crumbly like a feta, cotija, or queso fresco. It won’t be absolutely terrible with any cheese though, so if you really love cheese and you must have your rosé, then please go rosé all day with your cheese plate!
Red wines: Here’s the thing. I always picture red wine and cheese in my head. However, a lot of cheeses can actually make red wines taste hollow or flat and a lot of soft cheeses, like brie or burrata, can’t stand up to the intensity of the red wines. The way to impress your dinner guests is by bringing out those nutty, hard cheeses like gruyere and comte, fruitier cheeses with umami like cheddar, gouda, or muenster, and those dryer, salty and umami cheeses like parmesan, pecorino, or asiago
Tl;dr: Unless you’re drinking a dessert wine, like a vintage port, maybe don’t do the blue cheese. Creamy, soft cheeses (like brie or burrata) and nutty, hard cheese like (Gruyere, Provolone, comte, and mozzarella) are your safest bets across most wines!
Except for rosé. Go drink your rosé in the pool and leave the cheese in your kitchen.
A final fun fact: In 2016, French researchers found that consuming cheese while drinking wine can improve the experience of drinking wine itself! In addition, the effect is also cumulative which means that instead of your palate becoming overwhelmed, it becomes even more sensitive. A good reason to save your best wines for last.
And a final, final thought:
Ultimately, the point is to enjoy the wine and cheese. If you absolutely love brie and you absolutely love a bold, red wine, you do you! Everyone’s palate is unique and these are just guidelines. If you’re pairing a cheese you don’t like with your wine just because the “rules” say so, what’s the point?
Stacey Gibson
Sommelier, President of Women in Wine, Oregon, and More
Merobebe
Tell us a little about yourself!
Stacey Gibson
I am a sommelier and I own Parallel Food & Drink, a food and wine event company with my husband, who's a chef. We focus on wine pairings and dinners, and we work with a lot of wineries. I also do monthly wine clubs, so we do that and specialty retail.
I am also the president of Women in Wine, Oregon, which is a 1-year term, and have been on the board for a few years.
Merobebe
You don’t have enough things going on! Let's start at the beginning. What first interested you in wine and actually working in the wine industry?
Stacey Gibson
I went to college, got a Political Science degree, and lived and worked in D.C. for about a year and a half. I even went to graduate school for public policy for a semester. But I just saw no future. Nothing in it was what I wanted to be doing.
My best friend was working at a restaurant in the Flatiron District of New York, and she was like, Just move here, work in my restaurant, live with me – just come to New York. And I thought, You know what? That sounds great. So I was a hostess at a restaurant, and that’s where I met my husband.
Once I realized that I wanted to stay in restaurants, I was trying to find my niche and gravitated towards wine. I've always loved wine, even when I didn't know anything about it. It’s so easy to get sucked into because there’s so many elements to it. I’m a Polisci girl, so even the bureaucracy of wine is fascinating. It's annoying, but it's fascinating – the way each country does it, the way the EU does it, the way they determine who gets to put what on each label, the history of how they came to be. It's so, so interesting.
I [decided that I] wanted to be a wine director, so I was looking for positions that would get me there and I started working at Momofuku Má Pêche when it opened. It was about a three year process from when I started working at restaurants, took all these courses [and got my WSET Level 3], and then really started as a wine director. I eventually was a wine director at Má Pêche, but only for about like nine months. I think I did a good job, but I definitely felt over my head in the wine world. didn't know the producers as well as I needed to. I was just really young.
Then, one of my bosses at Má Pêche became the director of operations for Laura Maniec’s CorkBuzz, a wine bar in Union Square. Laura is a master sommelier, so I jumped over to open CorkBuzz as a somm and I worked there for a couple of years. While I was there, I took Levels 1 - 3 of the Court of Master of Sommeliers.
Merobebe
What does it mean to be a restaurant wine director?
Stacey Gibson
It can be the same as a sommelier, but ultimately the wine director is the one selecting the wine, buying the wine, putting it on the list, making sure your costing is right. You're also in charge of the finances so when you buy something, you have to price it correctly, put it on the list, make sure that the list is printed correctly, that the button in the computer is charging the correct amount, and that you are storing the wine in a way that your team can find it.
It's making sure all those systems work well. But ultimately, the fun part is you get to make the decision! You get to have tasting appointments with [wine sales] reps and decide if you’ll take a case of this or put something on the glass list.
Once you make a selection, it's mostly a job of logistics and making sure the whole program is running how you wanted and how you envisioned. If a guest comes in and they want a sauvignon blanc by the glass but you don’t have it, you need to have something else that the customer will enjoy. So you’re also filling in holes and making sure you have something for everyone – you want to make sure everyone is happy when they come into your restaurant.
Merobebe
As the wine director, do you work closely with the culinary team so that if there's a menu update you can adjust the wine list?
Stacey Gibson
That depends on the restaurant but ideally, that's exactly right. Sometimes, they just tell you that they’re adding a menu item and to make sure the wine goes with it. That's also something that we do with Parallel that is a little different and is why it's so much fun.
My husband loves food and cooking – he's passionate about it. He gets excited about wine pairings, especially as a chef, and one of his favorite things is for me to pick the wine and then work backwards. It’s an extra little challenge for him that is fun. But that is really rare. Usually, the food comes first, and then the wine. It depends on the restaurant. Sometimes, like at CorkBuzz, all of the food is incredibly wine friendly.
Merobebe
It would be fun to have a wine flight with a food pairing instead of the other way around!
Stacey Gibson
That’s why we started Parallel. We started with pop ups where we started with the wine first and then built the menu around it. We had a lot of fun with that and then transitioned to catering and now we've been doing more different styles of events, but we want to do more pop ups because they’re so fun and we get to do great pairings.
One of our favorite pairings was from a Portland-based winery called Teutonic. They buy a lot of their grapes from around the Willamette Valley and make a wine they call their Red Blend. It’s gewürztraminer left on the skin, so it’s red, which is then co-fermented with Pinot Noir. It was highly aromatic and we made a seafood curry soup with it. [My husband] was literally making a dish for this wine, which is just so creative and cool.
The wine is just wild and I don't think it would have worked the other way – to have a dish and then be like, You know what would go well with this? A skin contact gewürztraminer that’s co-fermented with pinot. It just wouldn't work that way. That's the kind of stuff that gets us excited that we've been a little away from.
Merobebe
You have Parallel, you're an advanced sommelier, have been a contributing writer for Serious Eats, and worked at various restaurants. Have you faced any challenges being a woman in the male-dominated field of wine and food?
Stacey Gibson
I have a lot of answers depending on the angle. I've had really good male mentors and bosses when I was coming up in the industry. I felt very supported. I felt like there were a lot of men who saw my potential and supported me – but that was also in the wine bubble within the restaurant.I will say with restaurant management, it's tough because it's hard being a boss in general. When you’re a manager, sometimes you have to make decisions that people are not happy with.
I have this distinct memory – I was the GM and wine director at a restaurant here in Portland, and that was definitely hard for me because it wasn't a wine restaurant and no one appreciated my wine background at all, which was fine. It was also good for me at the time because it's right when I had my daughter and it worked out with scheduling, so I was happy to be working there. It was a really big staff and there were a lot of men on the staff that were mean and I know they still don’t like me. I definitely feel like if it was a man telling them the things I told them, it would have gone differently. There’s still very much the stigma of being shrill, for example. Instead of being a strong boss, you’re a bitchy woman.
There's also still those times where people don't think that I’m the boss. I used to own a wine shop, and one time we had agreed to have a Netflix show film at our shop. It was really cool. Me and one of my employees were clocked out and having so much fun. We were just tucked into a corner, drinking beer and watching. It was such a blast. And the whole night, we were talking to one of the crew members and helping him with whatever he needed, like making sure the AC was shut off and whatnot.
Later in the night, one of our regular customers was walking by and he came in to check it out. We were just chatting when the crew member came over and asked the customer if he was the owner. I was like, This guy? No, I’m the owner. This guy doesn’t even work here.It was kind of bizarre. A white man walks in and you jump to that? You’ve been talking to the owner for 5 hours!
Merobebe
You're the president of Women in Wine, Oregon. Tell us a little bit about what the organization does and why the work you do there is so important.
Stacey Gibson
I’m super jazzed about the work we're doing. It started about five years ago as an annual conference and that's the centerpiece of what we do. But over the five years, we've grown to include year-round happy hours and events, and we're launching a mentorship program. We switched to a membership program where you pay an annual fee and get discounts to the conference and to the happy hours. We also do virtual events that we're going to stick with because they've been pretty successful. It also helps because we really want to be a statewide organization and members down in southern Oregon can participate in the virtual events which are free for members.
I’m excited to see where we keep going. Every president has to lead the ship, and I'm surrounded by a lot of really passionate women. We happen to only have women on our board, although we have had men on our board and we would absolutely let men come to any of our events. We've had some men come to the annual conference. It's really about just being inspired and getting together.
It’s really great for the women in the wine industry because I think of my experience, too – not just breaking up the old boys club but when you put women in a room together, they're going to do some cool stuff.
That's a lot of what Women in Wine, Oregon does. Creating connections to get women in a room together and then let some magic happen because in a lot of ways, you just need to get information. You get different people that wouldn't have necessarily met each other to talk together. I love hearing people say, I met this woman at an event and now I have a job offer because I was able to get my resume to the top of the pile. That is exactly what we want to do. We always talk about how when you put women in charge of a community, they are going to work hard for everybody.
It's funny because there are so many great men out there, really, truly. But sometimes when you see women winemakers and business owners, especially small business owners, they really care about their community and they want to make sure they're taking care of their employees. They're more intentional about how they see their employees and how they're providing for their employees.
Merobebe
What are some other ways that you think that the wine industry can better not only support but also promote the work of female wine growers and business owners?
Stacey Gibson
I think women are already doing really amazing things and sometimes it’s just letting other people know, with marketing and PR – pushing women to the front. For women winemakers, sometimes that’s just access to sales channels or capital and the ability to hire someone to run their tasting or hire someone to do national sales while they’re doing the [winemaking]. I also think women tout themselves less, so we need to find a way to be like, Here’s my brand, and really putting it out front and building confidence.
I mean, there’s so many ways but I think a lot of it goes back to access to capital because you could be the best winemaker in the world who's making 100 cases a year. But if you don’t have the money, you can’t buy more grapes to make more wine, or to market it. I think that’s also just a small business issue as well. And then it’s, how do I take the next step? How can it sustain you personally? How can you live off of it? And a lot of that is marketing, which can be expensive. It’s important to let women tell their stories!
Get a wine-related movie or book pairing for your weekend.
Today’s pairing is The Billionaire’s Vinegar: The Mystery of the World's Most Expensive Bottle of Wine by Benjamin Wallace.
This New York Times bestseller follows the true story of a 1787 Château Lafite Bordeaux that was supposedly owned by Thomas Jefferson and sold for $156,000 at an auction. As the mystery unravels, you’ll meet the obsessive wine collector who discovered the bottle, a bicycle-riding British auctioneer, and other intriguing players. Was the bottle entombed in a Paris cellar for hundreds of years, or did it come from a secret Nazi bunker? Is it all part of an elaborate con?
See the reviews and buy The Billionaire’s Vinegar from a local bookstore here.
Share the wine wisdom with your friends!
If you enjoyed what you read, please consider forwarding it on to your fellow wine-loving friends! After all, sharing wine & wine (and cheese!) wisdom is the best kind of caring…
Next week, we’ll be talking about what exactly terroir is and why it matters, then I’m excited to share the story of Isabelle Simi, the first female winemaker.
Have a wine-derful week and see you next Wednesday!
Cheers,
Megumi